Violation ruling on detention during judicial control

img

AMED – The Constitutional Court ruled that Songül Kapancı’s “right to liberty and security” was violated after she was re-arrested on the same charges following her release under judicial control. 

The Constitutional Court (AYM) issued a violation ruling in the case of Free Women’s Movement (Tevgera Jinên Azad-TJA) activist Songül Kapancı, who was initially detained on charges of “terror organization membership” and later released under judicial control, only to be re-arrested on the same grounds. The Court noted that despite attending hearings after her initial release, a second arrest was ordered, which posed a threat to her right to liberty and security. 
 
Songül Kapancı was first detained on April 29, 2021, and an indictment was filed on May 3, 2021, alleging “terror organization membership”. She was released under judicial control after the first hearing on September 20, 2021. On March 19, 2022, the Diyarbakır Chief Public Prosecutor’s Office ordered her re-arrest under a new investigation based on the same charges. The indictment, citing “continuity of actions,” was merged with the previous case. On May 18, 2022, she was again released under judicial control.
 
At the final hearing of the merged case on June 21, 2023, Diyarbakır 11th High Criminal Court acquitted Songül Kapancı in the merged file but sentenced her to 6 years and 3 months in prison in the main case on charges of “terror organization membership”. 
 
Her objection to the second arrest was rejected by the Diyarbakır 9th Criminal Judgeship of Peace on March 30, 2022. She filed an individual application to the Constitutional Court on April 29, 2022, claiming the second detention violated her right to liberty and security. 
 
VIOLATION DECISION 
 
The Constitutional Court reached a decision three years later, ruling that Songül Kapancı’s detention on March 19, 2022, violated her right to liberty and security. The Court emphasized that she was detained a second time over similar incidents that led to her first detention and noted that the local court did not adequately explain why judicial control measures were insufficient despite her compliance. 
 
The ruling stated: “Considering that the applicant complied with judicial control and attended the next hearing, the lack of a concrete explanation as to why judicial control was inadequate compared to detention was deemed a deficiency.”
 
The Court found that there was insufficient evidence to justify the proportionality of the detention and concluded that the measure violated the safeguards under Article 19 of the Constitution. 
 
NOT REVIEWED  
 
The Court deemed Songül Kapancı’s oter claims, related to violations of “freedom of expression,” “freedom of association” and “freedom of assembly” inadmissible for review.  Songül Kapancı plans to appeal these rejected claims to the European Court of Human Rights (ECHR).
 

View More Articles

02/07/2025
09:19 ‘Workers must be the subject of the process’
09:18 Increased Pressure on Kurds in Iran: Demand for autonomy suppressed
01/07/2025
16:17 Details of the draft DEM Party to submit for the commission
15:15 European Delegation Visits DEM Party in Istanbul
15:07 Family of Rozerin Çukur Reacts to Constitutional Court Ruling: We could not find justice
13:09 Delegation from Europe submits petition to meet Abdullah Öcalan
13:00 Fatma Bostan Ünsal: Concrete legal and political steps must accompany peace rhetoric
11:50 Bar Association Chairs urge TBB to form legal monitoring committees
11:10 Seferi Yılmaz: Everyone must work for peace against war profiteers
09:39 Let’s hold firmly to the process says Writer Faik Tac
08:32 Tatvan festival: We women are ready for process
08:27 Operation against CHP members in Izmir: Tunç Soyer detained
30/06/2025
17:00 Amed Ecology Assembly: Let's defend nature with communes
14:54 Women's festival on its second day
14:15 Kerim Boran releases
11:46 Mothers: Unity must be achieved
10:57 People want to meet Abdullah Öcalan to come to Turkey
10:42 Civil society organisations call on government to take steps
10:14 4 years since the Istanbul Convention cancelled: We will not give up
09:26 Presidential pardon for ill prisoner Boran
29/06/2025
15:24 Struggle of the Kurdish people will end in victory says DBP Chair Bayındır
14:21 'Women should be involved in process'
13:48 Labour in Democratic Society Workshop: Let’s be builders, not watchers
12:25 War increases the number of disabled
11:56 According to Constitutional Court, killing of Rozerin Cukur lawful!
10:43 Journalists: Those threatening our colleague must be prosecuted
10:28 The problems of the 'Others' await solutions
09:47 Constitutional jurist Yokuş: The process will succeed with legal guarantees
08:00 Final declaration of Sheikh Seid conference published
27/06/2025
18:04 Call for Freedom of Abdullah Öcalan at UK Parliament
16:26 Rights organisations declare start to work to contribute to process
15:00 Şırnak Journalists Association: We stand by Zeynep Durgut
14:56 Prison report: Even the most basic human rights have been suspended
13:50 Abdullah Öcalan sends message to conference in Brussels
12:12 Families apply to İmralı Directorate
11:15 From Amed to the government: Call to ‘take action and end operations’
09:25 ‘Child detention increases crime rates’
09:25 Meral Danış Beştaş: Developments in the Middle East urge Turkey to resolve its internal issues
09:24 Lost four family members during the conflict: The state must take steps
09:23 Crisis felt in Wan and Qers: The solution lies in peace
09:22 Father of two sons buried under a sidewalk: Only peace can ease our pain
08:37 5 regions declared as 'special security zones' in Şirnex
26/06/2025
16:53 Bakırhan call for support for 'process' in his contacts in the UK
15:57 Human Rights Organizations to government: Comply with UN’s report on life sentences
15:00 Ikram Balekani: The solution for Iran is Democratic Confederalism
14:19 'Freedom Watch' enters its 14th year
13:08 The process has reached an important stage say İmralı delegation
12:24 Dubbins warns EU about process: It would be catastrophic if moment not seized
11:22 Threat to our reporter who uncovered the 'Prostitution Gang'
11:09 Circassians on the ‘Process’: Democracy is everyone’s issue, stereotypes must be broken